ROBERT L. TRENTHAM v. MID-AMERICA APARTMENTS, LP ET AL.

M2021-01511-SC-R11-CV

Case Overview

Inter. Case No. Style Trial Court Trial Court Judge Trial Court No.
M2021-01511-COA-R3-CV ROBERT L. TRENTHAM v. MID-AMERICA APARTMENTS, LP ET AL. Williamson County Circuit Court Binkley, Michael 19CV-414

Case Milestones

Description Date
Application Filed 03/13/2023
Application Disposition 07/13/2023
Record Filed
Appellant(s) Briefing Complete 09/22/2023
Appellee(s) Briefing Complete 10/20/2023
Oral Argument/Submission 12/06/2023
Decision Date
Decision Type
Disposition
Panel Jeffrey S. Bivins; Holly Kirby; Roger A. Page; Sarah K. Campbell; Dwight E. Tarwater
Closed Date

Parties

Names Role Counsel
Trentham, Robert L. Appellee/Plaintiff Malone, Charles Ingram
Mid-America Apartments, LP Appellant/Defendant Parsley, Robert F

Case History

Date Event Filer PDF
01/04/2024 Order-Withdrawal of Counsel Granted PDF
12/21/2023 Motion-Withdraw as Counsel Adamson, Virginia Nicole (Attorney) PDF PDF PDF PDF
12/06/2023 Docket Activity-Heard
11/17/2023 Brief-Appellee's Reply Brief Filed Trentham, Robert L. (Appellee/Plaintiff)
11/03/2023 Appellate Record-Checked Out to Court
11/03/2023 Brief-Reply Brief Filed Mid-America Apartments, LP (Appellant/Defendant)
11/02/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Filed Tennessee Trial Lawyers Association (Amicus Curiae)
11/02/2023 Order-Amicus - Leave to File Brief Granted PDF
10/27/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Lodged Tennessee Trial Lawyers Association (Amicus Curiae)
10/27/2023 Motion-Amicus Request for Participation Tennessee Trial Lawyers Association (Amicus Curiae) PDF PDF
10/25/2023 Administrative Order-Pro Hac Vice Admission Allowed PDF
10/20/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Filed Public Entity Partners (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal Attorneys Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal League (Amicus Curiae)
10/20/2023 Order-Amicus - Leave to File Brief Granted PDF
10/20/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Filed Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America (Amicus Curiae)
10/20/2023 Order-Amicus - Leave to File Brief Granted PDF
10/20/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Filed National Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae)
10/20/2023 Order-Amicus - Leave to File Brief Granted PDF
10/20/2023 Case Status-APPELLEE BRIEFING COMPLETE
10/20/2023 Brief-Appellee's Brief Filed Trentham, Robert L. (Appellee/Plaintiff)
10/20/2023 Motion-Pro Hac Vice Request Trentham, Robert L. (Appellee/Plaintiff); Malone, Charles Ingram (Attorney) PDF PDF PDF
10/19/2023 Administrative Order-Pro Hac Vice Admission Allowed
10/19/2023 Notice (Incoming)-Correspondence Received Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America (Amicus Curiae); Trent, Edward Howard (Attorney)
10/12/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Lodged National Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae)
10/12/2023 Motion-Amicus Request for Participation National Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae) PDF PDF
10/05/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Lodged Metropolitan Government of Nashville & Davidson Co. (Amicus Curiae); Public Entity Partners (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal Attorneys Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal League (Amicus Curiae)
10/05/2023 Motion-Amicus Request for Participation Metropolitan Government of Nashville & Davidson Co. (Amicus Curiae); Public Entity Partners (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal Attorneys Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal League (Amicus Curiae) PDF PDF
10/04/2023 Docket Activity-Attorney Confirmed Oral Argument
10/02/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Lodged Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America (Amicus Curiae)
10/02/2023 Motion-Pro Hac Vice Request Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America (Amicus Curiae); Trent, Edward Howard (Attorney) PDF PDF
10/02/2023 Motion-Amicus Request for Participation Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America (Amicus Curiae) PDF PDF
09/22/2023 Case Status-APPELLANT BRIEFING COMPLETE
09/22/2023 Brief-Appellant's Brief Filed Mid-America Apartments, LP (Appellant/Defendant)
09/11/2023 Docket Activity-Docketed (Oral Argument)
07/24/2023 Order Related to Extension-Granted PDF
07/20/2023 Motion for Extension to File-Brief Mid-America Apartments, LP (Appellant/Defendant) PDF PDF PDF PDF
07/13/2023 Order-TRAP 11 Granted PDF
07/13/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Filed Public Entity Partners (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal Attorneys Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal League (Amicus Curiae)
07/13/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Filed National Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae)
06/14/2023 Notice (Incoming)-Notice of Appearance Filed Mid-America Apartments, LP (Appellant/Defendant) PDF PDF
06/14/2023 Notice (Incoming)-Notice of Appearance Filed Mid-America Apartments, LP (Appellant/Defendant) PDF PDF
06/14/2023 Order-Substitution of Counsel Granted PDF
06/14/2023 Motion-Substitute Counsel Mid-America Apartments, LP (Appellant/Defendant) PDF PDF PDF PDF
04/21/2023 Response-to Motion Trentham, Robert L. (Appellee/Plaintiff) PDF PDF
04/20/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Lodged Public Entity Partners (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal Attorneys Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal League (Amicus Curiae)
04/20/2023 Motion-Amicus Request for Participation Public Entity Partners (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal Attorneys Association (Amicus Curiae); Tennessee Municipal League (Amicus Curiae) PDF PDF
04/13/2023 Brief (Other)-Amicus Brief Lodged National Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae)
04/13/2023 Motion-Amicus Request for Participation National Apartment Association (Amicus Curiae) PDF PDF
04/10/2023 Answer-to TRAP 11 Trentham, Robert L. (Appellee/Plaintiff)
03/21/2023 Order Related to Extension-Granted PDF
03/15/2023 Motion for Extension to File-Answer Trentham, Robert L. (Appellee/Plaintiff) PDF PDF
03/14/2023 Notice (Outgoing)-Lead Counsel Designated
03/13/2023 Initiating Document-TRAP 11 Permission to Appeal Mid-America Apartments, LP (Appellant/Defendant)
**NOTE: The case history section will include a column that will allow for the display of permitted documents in a PDF format.

Record Information

Volume Type Volumes Record Type
Technical Record 7 Original
Transcript of Evidence 6 Original
Exhibits 37 Original
Other 2 Original
Technical Record 1 Supplemental
Depositions 7 Supplemental